When politicians change parties, voters are left trying to work out what changed: the party, the politician, or the calculation about how to win. When those changes happen repeatedly, the question becomes more difficult. People want to know what their representatives believe and whether those beliefs will survive the next election.
That was where I began my conversation with Elenore Sturko. Introducing herself as the leader of CentreBC, she described a journey through the BC Liberals, the Conservatives, and a period as an independent. Before politics, she served in the RCMP. She said her experience with mental illness, addiction, and the challenges people faced on the street helped motivate her to run.
I wanted to understand what held that political journey together. Sturko describes herself as a centrist, but that word can mean different things to different people. Does it describe a coherent set of principles, a willingness to borrow useful ideas, or simply a position between two larger parties? Her answer connected a public argument about representation with a much more personal question about what she was willing to accept to remain in politics.
What does the middle stand for?
I asked Sturko to explain CentreBC’s values without relying on where it sits relative to its opponents. Being in the middle does not automatically tell voters what a party would do with their money, their schools, or their health-care system.
“We are a fiscally prudent, socially responsible party,” she said.
Her description combined support for resource development and economic growth with protecting public services and rejecting discrimination. She argued that someone could favour firmer responses to crime and addiction while also defending LGBT inclusion. Those positions, in her account, belong together.
That is a potentially meaningful definition of the centre. It also needs testing. Almost every party describes its spending as responsible and its policies as compassionate. The distinction becomes clearer when competing commitments collide: when protecting services costs money, when tax reductions reduce revenue, or when a coalition includes people with fundamentally different social values.
Sturko acknowledged one of those tensions when discussing campaign promises. Parties can all promise economic growth, she said, but growth takes time. Cutting revenue before that growth arrives can deepen the financial problem. Her argument was that credibility requires admitting what a government cannot immediately deliver.
The same standard should apply to her own proposals. A description of sensible government is a starting point; voters still need to see the costs and choices behind it.
When does compromise become surrender?
Sturko said she joined the Conservatives believing she would be part of a broad coalition focused on the province’s core problems. She described an experience that departed sharply from those expectations, including hostility towards her as a gay woman. Those are her accounts of the internal environment, rather than findings established by this interview.
Her explanation for refusing a return to the party centred on her family. She recalled discussing the possibility with her spouse and daughter and thinking about what her children had already witnessed.
“They saw me crying, you know, when things happened and it was so difficult at times.”
For Sturko, the decision involved more than choosing the likeliest route back to the legislature. It involved explaining to her children why she would return to an environment she believed had treated her badly.
“That’s not the lesson I want to show my children.”
That answer made the personal stakes clear. It did not erase the questions about her earlier decision to join. In fact, she acknowledged that decision in unusually direct terms:
“I felt in 2024 I actually stood up for something I didn’t believe in.”
There is a distinction between claiming never to have compromised and admitting that a compromise went too far. Her argument depended on the latter. Voters must decide whether that admission demonstrates growth and accountability, and whether it adequately explains the choices that preceded it.
Is influence worth the cost?
I put the practical problem to her: choosing a newer, less established party can mean losing the opportunity to serve. For someone who believes they can help their community, seeking a viable route to office is an understandable consideration.
Sturko recalled a conversation about whether it was better to have a place at the table or remain outside it. Her response exposed the limitation of that familiar argument.
“Of course it’s always better to be at the table. But when people sitting at that table with you are throwing rocks at you.”
Her point was that access and influence are different things. A seat inside a party does not necessarily allow someone to change its direction, particularly if they feel pressured to conceal commitments that brought them into public life.
She also described criticism from people in her own community who believed her presence had given the Conservatives credibility. That raises a difficult question for anyone attempting change from within: how do you judge whether you are improving an institution or helping it avoid scrutiny?
There is no universal answer. Refusing every compromise can make governing impossible. Accepting every compromise can leave a representative unable to explain what their presence achieves. What matters is whether politicians can identify their limits and account for the consequences of enforcing them.
What happens when the centre must choose?
I asked what Sturko would do if her party held influence in a legislature where another party needed support. She was strongly critical of the NDP and said an alliance was unlikely, while leaving room for discussions. She also saw areas of agreement with the Conservatives on public safety and recovery-oriented care, alongside significant disagreements on social issues.
That is where her argument would face its hardest test. A party presenting itself as an alternative may eventually have to help one of its opponents govern. Voters deserve to know which commitments would guide that decision and which concessions would be unacceptable.
Is there room for the political centre? Sturko believes there are voters whose priorities do not fit comfortably within the larger parties. This conversation explained why she wants to represent them. Whether that becomes a durable political alternative will depend on clear policies, credible compromises, and a consistent account of where she draws the line.
Watch or listen to the full interview on Nuanced. with Aaron Pete, and let me know: what would a party need to demonstrate to earn your trust in the political centre?



Thanks, Aaron. Sturko has been a strong and sane voice on the addiction issue and the really wrong and dangerous turns taken in BC. Appreciate this honest discussion of the challenges of a more 'nuanced' political approach- about which you both know a lot for sure.